My sister and I watched the first Harry Potter movie over Labor Day weekend and wanted to celebrate the occasion by trying one of the recipes from the HP books. Butterbeer comes up so often we couldn't resist, even though it was a bit tricky finding a vegan version.
Ultimately, we decided to go with
this recipe because it called for the least obscure / costly ingredients (I didn't want to spring for some butterscotch extract, for example!) although we looked quite foolish wandering around the beer aisle looking for a "flavorful dark beer"; we don't drink so I'm pretty clueless about that sort of thing. Anyway, we picked one that looked promising (Fat Tire from Fort Collins, CO if anyone out there is a fan, haha!), got home, and set to boiling out the alcohol.
We halved the recipe, used almond milk instead of soy, but otherwise followed the recipe exactly. (I don't even want to know how much fat and sugar was in that cupful!) Anyway, the result was definitely.... interesting! Warm, autumn-y spices, tangy, with sweet undertones and a funky kick (probably the taste of the beer we aren't used to, alcohol or not!) On the one hand, I'm not sure I exactly liked it, but yet I found it extremely fascinating! Ultimately, though, it was just a bit "much" so we left our glasses mostly full, scooped out the rest of the soy ice cream, and poured a bit of the butterbeer over it for flavoring ;-) I think next time we will try one of the cream soda based recipes; this one just wasn't "butterscotchy" enough for what I always imagined butterbeer to taste like.
Still, it was quite fun :-) I think we might try pumpkin pasties for the next film!